1(904)362-3629 [email protected]

What Does a Post-COVID Economic Recovery Look Like for Women?

In the early months of 2020, as COVID-19 barrelled across the world, experts began to understand that this particular crisis was going to look a little lopsided. It was clear from the start that women would be the ones on the front lines of the pandemic. Here in Canada, women make up the vast majority of nurses (90 percent), respiratory therapists (75 percent) and personal support workers in long-term care and nursing homes (90 percent). Theyre also far, far more likely to be behind the cash at a grocery store or cleaning hospitals, offices and schools. But as COVIDs economic impact came into focus, something else did, too: Women would be levelled by the financial fallout. And economists suspect the impact of this blow will be felt for years to come.Typically, recessions hammer industries like manufacturing, construction and natural resources sectors dominated by men. Thats what happened in 2008; its what happened back in the 1980s. When COVID arrived, though, it shut down all the industries that involve social contact: restaurants, retail, tourism, education, personal services, child care. Women disproportionately fill these workplaces, and they were all effectively laid off in a single week, says Katherine Scott, senior researcher with the Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives. Over March and April 2020, more than 1.5 million women became unemployed. Among workers ages 25 to 54 which is to say, most workers twice as many women as men lost their jobs. In fact, after just several weeks of the pandemic, there were fewer women working in Canada than at any time over the past 30 years.(Related: 8 Women Share the Impact the Pandemic Has Had on Their Mental Health)But women didnt lose only their jobs. With schools and child-care centres shuttered by COVID plus babysitters, friends, neighbours and grandparents all off limits for fear of transmission women lost their support systems as well. And, global pandemic or no, its abundantly clear who runs the unpaid economy. Women still take on the majority of care work, whether thats for children, elders or people with disabilities, says Carmina Ravanera, a research associate at the University of Toronto Rotman School of ManagementsInstitute for Gender and the Economy. How much care work are we talking about? One study found Canadian women had upped their caregiving from 68 hours a week pre-pandemic to 95 hours during COVID the equivalent of nearly two-and-a-half full-time jobs. Men averaged half that. So its no surprise who ends up leaving their employment to look after their families: In the first year of the pandemic, 12 times as many mothers as fathers quit their jobs to take care of toddlers or school-age children. Single mothers were even more likely to stop working.All told, in Canada, women have been 10 times as likely as men to fall out of the labour force, which means theyre no longer looking for employment. Its hardly a choice. After months now more than a year of home-schooling and caretaking and meal planning and Zoom meetings and working and cooking and cleaning and lockdown, something had to give. I am gobsmacked by the number of women I know who are just at their end and cant do it anymore, Scott says. That kind of churn is really damaging. But the expectation continues that women will drop out, absorb all this unpaid work and alone bear the long-term economic consequences of walking away.(Related: How Are Canadian Caregivers Handling COVID?)

At the start of the pandemic, as the world locked down and celebrities were crooning Imagine into their iPhones, we heard a lot about how COVID-19 was the great equalizer. The virus didnt care about socio-economic status, the reasoning went, and besides, every one of us has been undone by all this upheaval and isolation. Even Ellen joked that being stuck inside stuck inside her five-bedroom, 12-bathroom, pool-and-tennis-court-equipped California mansion is just like being in jail!Of course, COVID didnt do away with inequality. It accelerated the inequality that already existed. Plenty of workers didnt skip a paycheque or mortgage payment when the pandemic hit. Not only that, they sat at home and watched as they racked up savings and their assets appreciated, because its been one of those crazy years in the housing market, Scott says. Men are overrepresented in the scientific, professional and technical industries, which fairly seamlessly shifted to remote work. And as e-commerce boomed, these same sectors actually added 55,000 new jobs between February and October 2020 three-quarters of which went to men. For some people, this hasnt really been a recession at all, Scott says. Its quite a K-shaped recovery. Thats the term economists use for a wildly uneven economic trajectory: Those at the top grow wealthier, while those on the bottom sink further into debt. But here, too, inequality persists; not all women are struggling the same way. The pandemic has really affected those who are already marginalized in society, Ravanera says. So, broadly, women are leaving the labour force in large numbers, but weve seen that racialized and low-income women have been even more affected.”(Related: What We Should Take Away From The Year of Covid)Since February 2020, employment losses have been largest for people who earn the least a group thats overwhelmingly made up of racialized women. Nearly 60 percent of women making $14 or less (thats the lowest 10 percent of earners) were laid off or had the majority of their hours cut between February and April of last year. Even among all female earners, racialized women were hit harder: Nine months into the pandemic, the unemployment rate for minority women stood at 10.5 percent, compared to 6.2 percent for white women. For Black women, it was higher: 13.4 percent. For Indigenous women, higher still, averaging 16.8 percent from June to August 2020. Racialized and low-income women are disproportionately concentrated in roles that are not well-protected, that dont have paid sick leave, Ravanera says. So theyre more likely to contract the virus, theyre more likely to have to choose between their health and their work, and theyre facing higher rates of unemployment.And the implications of that loss will stretch long past the end of this pandemic. The rent wasnt cancelled it was deferred, Scott says. Were looking at large debts coming out of COVID, and itll take people years, if not decades, to climb out of that hole. That impacts not only their security but the security of their family and kids, and whether these young people are going to be able to go to post-secondary school. In Canada, women are more likely to carry student debt than men are; theyre more likely to owe more money than men do; and theyre much more likely to file for insolvency based on that debt. It just reinforces disadvantage, Scott says. It really drives the wedge.No wonder, then, that this pandemic is wreaking havoc on womens health as well as their wallets. Financial strain not being able to put food on the table, not being able to pay your monthly bills contributes to ongoing stress and has a negative effect on peoples mental health, says Dr. Samantha Wells, senior director at the Institute for Mental Health Policy Research at Torontos Centre for Addiction and Mental Health (CAMH). A report released at the start of 2021 from Leger and the Association for Canadian Studies found that over 40 percent of unemployed women surveyed described the state of their mental health during COVID as bad or very bad. (Just over a quarter of unemployed men said the same.) And during the pandemic, CAMH found women in general more likely than men to suffer increased anxiety and depressive symptoms.Its one more way COVID has compounded inequality that already exists. We know that women experience higher levels of anxiety and depression than men do, Wells says. We knew that before the pandemic in fact, those levels are twice as high. So of course women were hit terribly hard. You see that in the numbers. But you also hear it really, really hear it when you talk to your friends and family and colleagues and neighbours and, very likely, when you stop for a nanosecond to check in with yourself. Adds Wells, You hear it when women tell the story of how overwhelmed they are.(Related: Going the Distance: How Covid Has Remapped Friendships)Bh210437 Jello FnlAs the pandemic barrelled toward its first anniversary, an RBC report offered grim news: Nearly half a million Canadian women whod lost their jobs still hadnt returned to work as of January 2021, and 349,000 hadnt returned as of February. Theres always a concern that people who step away from the labour force will have a more difficult time getting back in; weve seen that with the so-called mommy penalty, where women experience a significant drop in their earnings for five full years after the birth of a child. But COVIDs sheer unpredictability complicates matters further. Theres so much that is unknowable, including how quickly the economy will get back into full gear and our appetite to return to the way things were, says Dawn Desjardins, deputy chief economist at RBC and one of the authors of the report. Will people want to eat in restaurants? Browse the shelves of tiny shops? Drop their kids off at daycare or put their parents in long-term care homes? I dont know whether that bounces straight back, she says.Nor does Desjardins know what the demand for labour will look like once this pandemic actually ends. Even before COVID, womens jobs faced a higher risk from automation, as AI made inroads into the services sector. Back in March 2019, another RBC report determined that women held 54 percent of the positions that were highly likely to be automated. That shakes out to 3.4 million jobs. And now? The pandemic has accelerated the digitization of business and e-commerce, Desjardins says. Will we need fewer people for that face-to-face contact? People have certainly become more accustomed to ordering their groceries or their clothes online.(Related: Covid, One Year Later: How to Move Ahead When the Tank Feels Empty)So what needs to happen here? In his September Throne Speech, Justin Trudeau acknowledged that women, particularly low-income women, had been hit hardest by the pandemic, and in March of this year just in time for International Womens Day Finance Minister Chrystia Freeland announced the creation of a female-led economic task force. A long-promised national child-care program seems closer to becoming a reality, which pretty much every economic expert will tell you is table stakes. The old approach to recovery, which is throwing money at guys in hard hats, is really not going to cut it this time, Katherine Scott says. Child care is absolutely critical.Beyond that, mandatory paid sick leave for all workers including part-time, low-wage and hourly workers is a no-brainer. (How are we still debating this in the middle of a pandemic?) So is setting a higher minimum wage. And so is understanding that these issues wont magically disappear once we all manage to get our COVID vaccines. For all the talk of these unprecedented times, theres lots of evidence to suggest womens labour, both paid and unpaid, has been deeply undervalued. And theres plenty of data to show racialized workers arent given the protection theyre due.Thats why any recovery plan needs to have equity at its centre, and why the people hit hardest by COVIDs fallout need to have the most say in the response. The cracks in our societys foundation have made us even more vulnerable to crises like this, and if we dont focus on who is most impacted, then those circumstances are going to continue, Carmina Ravanera says. Structural changes need to be put in place so that the recovery we have is long-lasting and so marginalized groups dont face the brunt of a downturn like this one again.Next, read about a death doula’s experience working during COVID.

The post What Does a Post-COVID Economic Recovery Look Like for Women? appeared first on Best Health Magazine Canada.

Site Link